THE USUAL OBJECTIONS: “THE BOY WILL BE TURNED INTO A HOMOPHILE”
BY EDWARD BRONGERSMA
Presented here is fifth part of “The Usual Objections”, a section of “Negative Aspects of Man/Boy Relations: Presumed and Real”, the fourth chapter of Loving Boys, the encyclopaedic study of Greek love by the eminent Dutch lawyer, Edward Brongersma, of which the second volume (including this) was published by Global Academic Publishers in New York in 1990.
“The Child Will Be Turned Into a Homophile”

For years everyone believed that if a boy had sexual relations with a man it would make the boy homosexual, and he would remain homosexual for the whole rest of his life. Obviously, then, boys should be protected from such contacts.
Despite the finding of Bell & Weinberg that, even in as desperately homophobic a society as that of North America, homophiles on the whole do not feel less happy than heterophiles,[1] it is not unreasonable to suppose that a young man would prefer not to belong to a minority with a considerably higher suicide rate,[2] which is discriminated against, rejected and persecuted in every society which has been heavily influenced by Christianity.[3] It is pleasant to read in Ford and Beach[4] that homosexuality is considered a quite normal phenomenon in 64% of the cultures which they investigated, but neither the European, nor the North American, nor the Soviet powers belong to this cultural majority of theirs. In many countries homophiles have no legal rights and so are at the mercy of their rulers, as in Cuba and in China,[5] and this does not seem to cause undue worry to those idealistic people among us who claim to be fighting for human rights. Thus it is quite understandable that parents prefer their sons to grow up as heterophiles rather than homophiles.
That a boy could be “converted” or “perverted” to homosexual preferences had already been proposed in Greek antiquity by the peripatetic school of philosophers – not in the absurd form it assumed later in the nineteenth century, but in teaching that passivity in anal intercourse might become a preferred sexual technique if continued over a long period of time.[6]
It was left to a more enlightened age to promulgate the blind belief that a single “seduction” by a man would make the poor boy ineluctably and inevitably and forever homophile. No honest heterophile could ever have invented this absurdity, for it presupposes that the homosexual experience was so fantastically wonderful that in one single sexual cataclysm all the effects of heterosexual indoctrination to which every boy is subjected by society for years on end is eliminated. Whoever has drunk but once from the source of homosexuality will ever after long for a repetition, so weak is the heterosexual impulse in comparison!

Such a testimonium paupertatis of heterosexuality was, of course, not invented by real heterophiles but by homophiles standing trial for homosexual “offenses”. To excuse their “criminal conduct” they claimed to have been victims in their youth of homosexual seduction. Perhaps they thought if they were going to be prosecuted by idiots it would be best to put forward an idiotic defence. But the sword they used cut both ways. Judges and public prosecutors gullibly swallowed the argument, only to conclude that they must fight all the harder against homosexuality as a corrupting influence on youth.
In reality the sequence of events is quite the reverse. If a boy reacts positively to a homosexual approach the reason is the presence within him of homosexual tendencies which, at least at the time, are strong enough to allow him to become sexually aroused.[7] In which direction his sexual preferences will gradually evolve is either innately determined or determined by environmental influences active during the very first years of his life – certainly before he goes to school.[8] All fear of “homosexual propaganda” or “homosexual proselytizing” is therefore groundless. It is as senseless to propagandize for homophilia as it is to propagandize for red-headedness, left-handedness, or having crossed eyes.
At the time when I was writing Das verfemte Geschlecht this problem of “seduction to homosexuality” was still central to all discussions about penal law reform. I thus devoted many pages to the issue, pointing to the shift in position of the Dutch psychiatrist Tolsma who as late as 1948 energetically supported the traditional seduction-to-homosexuality thesis but who was so laudably honest that when later he was confronted with conflicting fact he confessed that he had been mistaken and had altered his professional opinion. Thus in the 1963 edition of his book he wrote: “Permanent homosexual orientation is in our culture only to be found in individuals with a predisposition to it, that is to say in those in whom the tendency is already present before the seduction.”[9] As sharing this point of view, I quoted from Naecke,[10] Havelock Ellis,[11] Moll, Placzek,[12] Hirschfeld,[13] von Krafft-Ebing, Schwarz, Rozanoff,[14] Doshay,[15] Bender & Grugett,[16] Berg,[17] West,[18] the Roman Catholic committee presided over by the English cardinal Griffin (1956), the official British committee presided over by Sir John Wolfenden, Coon,[19] Klimmer,[20] Westwood, [21] Rainer,[22] Schlegel, Freund, Bieber,[23] Schofield, Marmor,[24] Sengers,[25] Churchill, de Batselier, Bräutigam,[26] Trimbos,[27] the Dutch official commission presided over by Prof. Speijer (1970). We may add Abraham,[28] Gagnon,[29] Geiser;[30] Harry;[31] Langfeldt[32] Powell & Chalkley;[33]Righton;[34] Zeegers;[35] Everaerd;[36] Haeberle.[37] It seems unnecessary now to cite all those passages which show how the seduction-to-homosexuality theory is nothing more than “an old wives’ tale”, as Hanack, law professor at the University at Heidelberg, and Bräutigam, his medical colleague there, called it.[38] Every so often we still hear its echoes, unfortunately not only from old wives but from the likes of Dr. Johannes Pohlschneider, bishop of the diocese of Aachen, who in 1976 repeated it with complete peace of mind in a treatise called Ethics of Christian Sexual Education.

A most convincing witness to its lack of veracity is the experience of the Sambia boys in New Guinea, as described by Herdt. In their tribal villages the Sambia segregate the sexes as much as possible. Men and women each have their own paths and meeting places. The boys have no contact whatever with the girls. The initiation process for them begins somewhere between ages 7 and 10. During the first phase, which lasts until they are about fifteen, they are expected to suck the penis of a mature boy every night and swallow his sperm. Without regular ingestion of male seed, the Sambia believe, boys will never grow up into strong, mature men. At first some of the boys dislike having to do this, but gradually all come to enjoy it and often strong ties of friendship are formed between the sucker and the sucked. After puberty the boys enter the second phase of initiation: it is now their turn to provide seed for the benefit of the younger ones. They do this until, at around age 22, they marry. Marriage terminates the young man’s homosexual life, since once his penis has penetrated a woman’s vagina it is no longer considered clean and it would be dangerous for any other male to touch it. What is of especial interest to us at this point is that after 10 to 15 years of exclusive homosexual activity carried on by 100% of the young male Sambia population, the incidence of adult homosexual orientation is only 5% – exactly the same as in Western society.[39]
Homosexual activity before or in the first years after puberty is neither cause nor early evidence of adult homosexual orientation. At puberty a boy needs to experiment with his sexuality, just as he has to try out his other physical and mental capacities, until he has found what suits him the best. This is the normal way every human being learns. Boys who have not been warped by their upbringing but are healthy in their psychosexual development will be observed experimenting with homosexuality, animal sex, exhibitionism, voyeurism (being peeping Toms) and fetishism.[40] As long as boys, in their sexual activities, respect the rights of others, there is not the least cause for concern. Such experiments will never hurt the youngsters themselves, only the possible panic reactions of the people around them.[41]

We might ask ourselves whether only adults should be allowed their exhibitionist pleasures, to dress up and pose, to take voyeuristic delight in spying on the intimacies of others in the pages of the yellow press, to sadistically enjoy acid criticism and biting jokes at the expense of absent persons, to derive sexual pleasure watching strip shows or looking at porno magazines, to experience homosexual sadistic excitement at a boxing match or auto races with the greatest chance of lethal, bloody accidents. Is not all of this veiled mental perversity far more symptomatic of a sexually traumatized personality than the adolescent boy’s open experimentation with sex could ever be?
In having sex with a peer or a man, the adolescent boy tries out the homosexual possibilities of his mental makeup instead of repressing them. Repression means not having them under control, and that could result in being obsessed by them. The man who in his youth has had his fling expressing his homosexual component, and then put it all by, will feel less driven as an adult by homosexual impulses than the man who didn’t. He will also find homosexuality less disturbing, view it with more understanding, because it is, for him, no longer a skeleton in the closet.
Of beautiful Alcibiades the story was told that as a boy he drove all husbands mad with love and enticed them away from their wives, while as a man he drove all women mad with love and enticed them away from their husbands.[42]

Continue to The Usual Objections: "The Partners Are So Unequal"
[1] Bell, A. P. & Weinberg, M. S., Homosexualities - A Study of Diversity Among Men and Women, London: Mitchell Beazley, 1978, p. 432. [Author’s note]
[2] Baudry, A., La condition des homosexuels, Toulouse: Privat, 1982, p. 82; Bleibtreu-Ehrenberg, G., Tabu Homosexualität–Die Geschichte eines Vorurteils, Frankfurt: Fischer, 1978, p. 402; Ell, E., Sexualethik und kriminalisierte Sexualität.In: Albrecht-Désirat&Pacharzina (Eds.), Sexualität und Gewalt. Bensheim: Päd-extra, 1979, p. 140; Tielman, R., Homoseksualiteit in Nederland, Meppel: Boom, 1982, p. 168; Siegfried, C.-F., Gesellschaft und Homosexualität, Burckhardthausverlag, 1979, p. 94; Wagner, Th., Neue Perspektiven in der Homophilenpastoral, Manuscript, 1979, p. 141; West, D., Homosexuality Re-Examined, London: Duckworth, 1977, p. 198. [Author’s note]
[3] Masters & Johnson 1988, 254 [Author’s note, but unidentifiable since there is no book by these authors listed in the bibliography as published in 1988].
[4] Ford, C. S. & Beach, F. A., Formen der Sexualität, Berlin: Rowohlt, 1968, p. 139. [Author’s note]
[5] Haeberle, E. J., The Sex Atlas, New York: Seabury, 1978, pp. 385-386. [Author’s note]
[6] Buffière, F., Eros adolescent–La pédérastie dans la Grèce antique, Paris: Les Belles Lettres, 1980, p.440; Bullough, V. L., Sexual Variance In Society and History. 3. Chicago: University of Chicago, 1976. p.104; Wagner, Th., Neue Perspektiven in der Homophilenpastoral, Manuscript, 1979. note 39. [Author’s note]
[7] Hanry, P., Les enfants, le sexe et nous, Toulouse: Privat, 1977, pp.117-120; West, D., Homosexuality Re-Examined, London: Duckworth, 1977, p. 54. [Author’s note]
[8] Batselier, S. de, “Kern-homofilie.” Streven20, 2: 440-448, 1967, p. 444; Baurmann, M. C., Sexualität, Gewalt und psychische Folgen, Wiesbaden: Bundeskriminalamt, 1983, (or possibly the 2nd edition of this book published later the same year by the same publisher as Sexualität, Gewalt und die Folgen für das Opfer -Brongersma does not make this clear) p. 72; Bieber. I et al, Homosexuality–a Psychoanalytic Study of Male Homosexuals. 17. New York: Vintage Books, 1962, p. 173; Bleuler, quoted by Wolfenden Committee, The Wolfenden Report. New York: Stein & Day, 1963. Sect. 68; Churchill, W., Homosexual Behavior Among Males, New York: Hawthorn, 1967, p. 214; Hart de Ruyter, Th. et al, De seksuele ontwikkeling van kind tot volwassene, Leiden: Stafleu, 1976, p. 143; Harry, J., “Sexual orientation as Destiny”.Journal of Homosexuality 10, 3/4: 111-124, 1984, p. 122; Hoult, Th. F., “A Brief Rejoinder”. Journal of Homosexuality 10, 3/4: 125, 1984, p. 125;Klimmer, R., Die Homosexualität, Hamburg: Kriminalistik, 1958, p. 93; Kwast, S. van der, Seksuelecriminaliteit, Leiden: Stafleu, 1968, p. 118; Sengers, W. J., De pastorale begeleiding van pedofielenenefebofielen. Tijdschrift voor Theologie7, 1967, p. 144; Wyss, R., Unzuchtmit Kindern, Berlin: Springer, 1967, pp. 44-5. [Author’s note]
[9] Tolsma, F. J., Homoseksualiteit en homoërotiek. Tweede druk. Den Haag: Bakker/Daamen, 1963, p. 141. [Author’s note]
[10] Naecke, P., Le monde homosexuel de Paris. 3. Archives d’Anthropologie Criminelle XX: 182-185, 1905. [Author’s note]
[11] Havelock Ellis (1915). [Author’s note, but the book is not listed in his bibliography]
[12] Placzek, Freundschaft und Sexualität, Bonn: Marcus, 1919. [Author’s note]
[13] Hirschfeld (1926). [Author’s note, but the book is not listed in his bibliography]
[14] Rozanoff (1935). [Author’s note, but the book is not listed in his bibliography]
[15] Doshay (1945). [Author’s note, but the book is not listed in his bibliography]
[16] Bender & Grugett (1952). [Author’s note, but the book is not listed in his bibliography]
[17] Berg (1954). [Author’s note, but the book is not listed in his bibliography]
[18] West (1955). [Author’s note, but the book is not listed in his bibliography]
[19] Coon (1957). [Author’s note, but the book is not listed in his bibliography]
[20] Klimmer, R., Die Homosexualität, Hamburg: Kriminalistik, 1958. [Author’s note]
[21] Westwood, G., A Minority, London: Longmans, 1960. [Author’s note]
[22] Rainer (1960). [Author’s note, but the book is not listed in his bibliography]
[23] Bieber. I et al, Homosexuality–a Psychoanalytic Study of Male Homosexuals, New York: Vintage Books, 1962. [Author’s note]
[24] Marmor (1965). [Author’s note, but the book is not listed in his bibliography]
[25] Sengers (1966). [Author’s note, but the book is not listed in his bibliography]
[26] Bräutigam, W. Formen der Homosexualität. 17. Stuttgart: Enke, 1967. [Author’s note]
[27] Trimbos, C. J. B. J., Homoseksualiteit: eeninleidendebeschouwing. In: Pastorale zorgvoorhomofielen. Utrecht: Spectrum, 1968. [Author’s note]
[28] Abraham, F., Les perversions sexuelles, Paris: Productions de Paris, 1969, pp. 209, 237. [Author’s note]
[29] Gagnon (1965 226). [Author’s note, but the book is not listed in his bibliography]
[30] Geiser, R. L., Hidden Victims–The Sexual Abuse of Children, Boston: Beacon Press, 1979, p. 92. [Author’s note]
[31] Harry, J., “Sexual orientation as Destiny”.Journal of Homosexuality 10, 3/4: 111-124, 1984, p. 118. [Author’s note]
[32] Langfeldt, Th., Processes in Sexual Development. Childhood Masturbation. In: Constantine & Martinson (Eds.), Children and Sex, Boston: Little, Brown & Co., 1981, pp. 41 [erroneous], 71-2. [Author’s note]
[33] Powell, G. E. & Chalkley, A. J., The Effects of Pædophile Attention on the Child. In: Taylor (Ed.), Perspectives on Pædophilia. London: Batsford, 1981, p. 77. [Author’s note]
[34] Righton, P., The Adult. In: Taylor (Ed.), Perspectives on Paedophilia. London: Batsford, 1981, p. 38. [Author’s note]
[35] Zeegers, M., Psychiatrie, Utrecht: Bohn, Scheltema & Holkema, 1977, p. 205. [Author’s note]
[36] Everaerd, W., Seks—En als dat nu eens niet lukt… In: Frenken (Ed.), Seksuologie, Deventer: Van Loghum Slaterus, 1980, p. 11. [Author’s note]
[37] Haeberle, E. J., The Sex Atlas, New York: Seabury, 1978, p. 176. [Author’s note]
[38] Hanack, E.-W., Empfiehlt es sich, die Grenzen des Sexualstrafrechts neu zubestimmen? München: Beck, 1968, p. 151. [Author’s note]
[39] Herdt, G. H., Guardians of the Flute - A Study of Ritualized Homosexual Behavior, New York: McGraw-Hill, 1981, pp. 2-4, 233 -234, 238, 280-282, 288, 319. [Author’s note]
[40] Karpman, B., The Sexual Offender and his Offenses, New York: Julian Press, [1954], p. 53. [Author’s note]
[41] Rabinovitch, quoted by Karpman, B., The Sexual Offender and his Offenses, New York: Julian Press, [1954], p. 556. [Author’s note]
[42] Buffière, F., Eros adolescent–La pédérastie dans la Grèce antique, Paris: Les Belles Lettres, 1980, p. 468. [Author’s note]
Comments powered by CComment